Auteur |
Message |
Sujet: War Wagon shooting |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 8
Vus: 598
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Dim Jan 08, 2023 8:48 pm Sujet: War Wagon shooting |
I agree that it's ambiguous. The WWg rules need a bit more work in general. |
Sujet: War Wagon shooting |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 8
Vus: 598
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Jan 07, 2023 9:33 pm Sujet: War Wagon shooting |
1) Remember the shooting priorities mean you can only target an enemy in the extension if there are none directly ahead.
2) That is what the rules say. Early cannon does have a flatter trajectory t ... |
Sujet: 2 COHESION LOSSES OR ONLY 1? |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 6
Vus: 552
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Ven Jan 06, 2023 12:32 am Sujet: 2 COHESION LOSSES OR ONLY 1? |
Keep in mind that is only what the (English) rules say. The DT might rule the intent was to keep in parallel with other types of losses in a phase. Hopefully we will know when they look at it. |
Sujet: 2 COHESION LOSSES OR ONLY 1? |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 6
Vus: 552
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Jan 04, 2023 4:50 pm Sujet: 2 COHESION LOSSES OR ONLY 1? |
Javier, this was asked recently, and the conclusion was that there is no restriction so 2, unlike the handling of other cohesion hits that are restricted to 1 per phase. |
Sujet: Exceptions to Uncontrolled Charge |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 28
Vus: 1982
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Lun Jan 02, 2023 4:56 pm Sujet: Exceptions to Uncontrolled Charge |
It's the same problem that causes people to think the 3CP cost applies every time the Impetuous unit is within charge range. The whole uncontrolled charge process is explained from start to finish and ... |
Sujet: Questions on bladed WWg |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 1
Vus: 256
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Déc 29, 2022 11:29 pm Sujet: Questions on bladed WWg |
Does a bladed WWg project a ZoC from its front short edge?
Bladed WWg's charge and conform entirely relative to the front short edge. They cannot, for example, wheel into enemy and conform with the ... |
Sujet: Q&A Summary |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 6
Vus: 850
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Déc 29, 2022 2:30 am Sujet: Q&A Summary |
I have revised the summary with questions asked since the previous version and deleted those resolved by the new errata.
If you find my mistakes or have other suggestions, please let me know. Please ... |
Sujet: Enemy lights and LOS |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 0
Vus: 249
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Déc 29, 2022 1:29 am Sujet: Enemy lights and LOS |
Enemy lights can be shot over by artillery. But do they block LOS to an ambush behind villages, plantation, woods, or hills? [I would assume no.] |
Sujet: Integrated Light Artillery |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 25
Vus: 4661
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Déc 28, 2022 10:38 pm Sujet: Integrated Light Artillery |
What about Dick's other question? Can you shoot at integrated artillery rather than its paired unit despite the LOS and Target Priority rules?
(In reality, I believe the mathematics of area fire mean ... |
Sujet: exiting a ZOC - choice of orientation? |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 39
Vus: 2953
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Déc 28, 2022 7:36 pm Sujet: exiting a ZOC - choice of orientation? |
I'm sitting here trying to write up this question for my Q&A summary, and I think maybe I was stumbling over a couple of difficulties in the rules and errata.
"On the flank" is defined ... |
Sujet: Rallying and Compulsory Conformation |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 12
Vus: 11483
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Déc 28, 2022 1:43 am Sujet: Rallying and Compulsory Conformation |
Note that there is more text about adjusting and rallying on page 39.
Also on page 40 a unit burst through may not then rally.
Is there any involuntary movement other than shifting, adjustment, un ... |
Sujet: Can Expendable Levies conform while in contact? |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 10
Vus: 1114
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Déc 24, 2022 12:27 am Sujet: Can Expendable Levies conform while in contact? |
I've overlooked the new errata, Bladed WWg cannot conform from non-melee contact. They must pay 1CP to move. Perhaps page 53 is supposed to say "cannot conform" rather than do not have to co ... |
Sujet: Can Expendable Levies conform while in contact? |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 10
Vus: 1114
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Ven Déc 23, 2022 4:53 pm Sujet: Can Expendable Levies conform while in contact? |
What part of "This isn't a live game where a referee's snap decision would be useful. Can we have some thoughts on the ramifications of this dusty corner which is obviously inconsistent?" do ... |
Sujet: Dismounting questions |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 3
Vus: 445
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mar Déc 20, 2022 4:11 pm Sujet: Dismounting questions |
Looks like bullet 4 overrides bullet 3, so HC Impact Bw or 1/2 Bw must dismount as HI Sp Support Armor 3 Cohesion. Semicolons don't seem to matter. |
Sujet: Can Expendable Levies conform while in contact? |
Za Otlichiye
Réponses: 10
Vus: 1114
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Déc 17, 2022 11:18 pm Sujet: Can Expendable Levies conform while in contact? |
I'm looking at this in preparation of summarizing it and I realize the root problem is the text on page 42:
War wagons (except those with blades), artillery and Expendable levies can never charge o ... |
|