Art De La Guerre

Thank you, Tim that is perfectly clear.

The 2021 Official Ruling is, shall we say interesting.

Consider this situation

ABC
123

Let's say ABC are all medium spears, 123 are impetuous Medium Sword charging

2 destroys B, the oth ...

I recall an extensive discussion of this. I believe the outcome was that during a charge, you must prefer conforming into melee, i.e. B would conform to unit 2. However if this situation arises due to ...

The battle line alignment can be, and often commonly is, accomplished in an earlier turn.

The more serious objection is your earlier point about it requiring voluntarily moving into a position wher ...

Hi Andy,

I saw where you were going with this question and it brought up something I had not considered. An interesting tactic.

Note two things -

1. If you start within 1 UD you can (obviou ...

This is pretty common - the answer is yes and yes

Hi Mike, yeah - English using the same word for different things causes some issues.

the page 67 definition of an obstacle refers to different types of obstacles than page 48 does.

Page 48 uses ...

Per page 49, third bullet, a slide is preferred to a wheel if a slide allows it to avoid the obstacle. So it moves back one UD, sees the HI it cannot interpenetrate one UD away and now maneuvers to av ...

There are four units involved here. 1, 2 and 3 are all on the same side facing down.

A is in melee with 1 and facing up

12
A3

it is now the player with the numbers turn. Both 2 and 3 m ...

[quote="][*]If the ‘blue’ MI win and rout the ‘red’ HC, the melee ends allowing the commander to be detached. If the ‘blue’ MI is subsequently routed through, the commander does not t ...

[quote=Nope, units who are routed at the call of Dice Down are counted as routed.[/quote]

Okay this entire thread is not a rules question - it is a "dice down" question. Dice down is not ...

Based on how page 26 is worded I think "at" the distance is sufficient.

it says you measure via a straight line from base to base and gives a maximum range. It does not say you must be w ...

Thank you Martin, most appreciated

So don't think of this as definitive, but Dan H and I asked Herve question #2 several years ago in Lisbon and his answer was that it did count as a charge with the usual first round factors taking eff ...

So don't think of this as definitive, but Dan H and I asked Herve question #2 several years ago in Lisbon and his answer was that it did count as a charge with the usual first round factors taking eff ...