Art De La Guerre

Here is a simple one that I don't know the answer to

H

LL

H is a unit of heavy infantry L and L represent two LI in a group. The left most LI is aligned with the HI

The LI move as a gro ...

Huh? Sure he can roll. It wont do anything but if you want to see if you can roll a 4-6 who am I to stop you. Just say you are retroactively rolling for a water way

To be clear, the roll of 4-6 ...

You could try, but then Tim Porter would fix you with a hard stare and you would have to sheepishly slink away.

So try this rationalization. Page 39 says if you "cannot" fully cross you ...

Wait Martin - aren't you the one that objected to looking at facebook in another post? And you want me to go to blog to get clarification for the diagrams you posted? Razz

I cant say if you are cor ...

Regardless, whenever an impetuous unit makes a charge it must endeavour to move its full (adjusted) distance, unless an explicit rule permits it to move less (e.g. reaching a support position, table ...

There doesn't seem to be a prohibition on a commander attaching to a unit outside their command. (Ok, this might fall into the category of "obvious oversight".) Presumably the commander move ...

The picture is essential to understanding the question. I did look at it.

You ask two questions. May it slide along the enemy? The answer is yes. See page 41 which is definitive on the subject. ...

Kevin, I am tired. What makes you say camps are units?

page 66 says that a camp "is treated as an enemy unit without a ZOC"

That does not make it a unit. It makes you treat it as a ...

Hi Kevin,

What is the target of the charge? The LI only or the El?

But notice it does not matter.

If the target was the LI then all targets have evaded and you perform step 6 Which makes yo ...

What an excellent question.

I would have answered "obviously yes" but then I read the first bullet on page 44 again.

So the question becomes, does the unit have to exert a Zone of Cont ...

I looked and did not see this already in the forum

1X
2Y
Z

1 is facing right. 2 is facing down

the other player has the letters

X and Y are facing left

Z is facing up

everyone bu ...

The LI does NOT prevent the HC quarter turn. LI can be interpenetrated in any direction.

Enemy LI may not be interpenetrated.

Each case of allowed interpenetration listed on page 39 includes th ...

You're probably correct.

Looks like the Getae are a mounted centric tribe that essentially swap the 0-4 medium cavalry and 4-8 lights with some bow for 0-4 medium cavalry bow and 4-8 bow lights ...

It is not explicit in the list but it seems to me that the Getae should be counted as a lowland tribe.

However the alternative is that they are a tribe on their own and, unlike Odrysians, do not be ...

I dont think you can find it because I dont think it exists. I might be wrong of course but this has been my understanding. You are exempted from an uncontrolled charge but not a conformation.

Th ...